Roof Overlay Vs Tear-Off: Which is Best?

When it is time to replace your roof, it becomes important to consider all relevant options.

The two most common options will include a roof overlay vs. tear off. These are distinct options that are going to be presented to you as the property owner.

So, which one is better? What are the pros and cons of each?

Here’s a detailed comparison of the differences between these two options for your roofing contractor in Rancho Santa Fe, CA.

Roof Structural Damage

Older properties should go with tear-off replacements to see what’s happening to the underlying structure. As a house age, new cracks can start to develop that will open up in the coming years.

This is where tear-off replacement help.

The idea is to remove the top layer and strip it down to just the foundation. From this point, a new roof is set up after inspecting the foundation.

While a roof overlay doesn’t allow you to see the structural damage as you are just going to work on top of what is already there.

Speed of Roof Installations

Are you someone that is on a strict timeline?

You are going to want to move things along and that is where roof overlays help. They are not going to take a long time to complete.

In comparison, tear-off replacements will take longer because the top layer will be removed to inspect the structure itself. This doesn’t happen with roof overlays.

Roof Affordability

A lot of people go with roof overlays because they are more cost-efficient.

If you are someone that is trying to work on a budget, the roof overlay might be better. It is going to save you more money and will require less labor.

On the other hand, you are going to get a more robust solution when you go with a tear-off replacement. This is something you are going to have to weigh when drawing up a detailed budget for the roofing project.

Safety

It is important to consider safety when it comes to a roofing change.

With a tear-off solution, you are going to get a chance to inspect the underlying foundation of the roof. This can help prevent leaks and/or cracks before they worsen.

Roof overlays will not allow you to do this as you can’t look at what’s happening underneath.

In wintry conditions, a tear-off roofing replacement will also make it easier to set up a new ice barrier. This can help prevent future damage to the room at a structural level.

Final Verdict

It all comes down to what your preference is.

In general, a tear-off replacement is going to be more comprehensive. However, it will be costly and is going to take longer in comparison to a simple roof overlay.

If you want a more robust solution to a longer-lasting roof along with an inspection of the structure, it makes sense to go with the tear-off solution. Otherwise, for those who want to save money and go with a more short-term solution, it’s okay to go with the roof overlay. In either case, you can contact a local roofing contractor in Rancho Santa Fe, CA, or the surrounding areas like Bob Piva Roofing for a free consultation of services.

‍